








USMLE Step 1 Forum USMLE Step 1 Discussion Forum: Let's talk about anything related to USMLE Step 1 exam 

Thread Tools  Search this Thread  Display Modes 
#1




What statistical analysis to compare these two groups?
Self made.
======= A researcher has designed a retrospective study, where patients undergoing laparoscopic and open operations for right hemicolecomy are compared. He has identified 30,000 patients records from National Inpatient Sample Database and created similar groups of patients treated by laparoscopic (N=15,000) or open (N=15,000) approach with matching demographical characteristics. Within the laparoscopic group, 5% died and within open 15% died. if he wants to compare the immediate perioperative outcomes for mortality within these two groups, what statistical test should he use? a. Fisher's exact test b. Paired T test c. ChiSquare test d. ANOVA e. TwoSample T test f. Relative Risk
__________________
Ambition is a dream with a V8 engine. EP 
#2




chi square because of the percentages?

#3




relative risk?
he wants to compare the same outcome [mortality] but in different procedures... open surgery is 3 x times more likely to die although relative risk is associated with cohort, which is a PROspective study, dunno :S whats the answer please , pm if u dont want to post it here now...
__________________
i'm so bad i make medicine sick, Imma show you how great i am 


#4




Dear DocSikorski
the correct answer is NONE! I know that you created this question... a. Fisher's exact test No for matched pairs b. Paired T test no for inference in proportions/rates c. ChiSquare test NO for matched pairs d. ANOVA no for inference in proportions/rates e. TwoSample T test no for inference in proportions/rates f. Relative Risk THIS is NOT a TEST. you should rewrite the question not using the "matched" assumption good luck to all! 
The above post was thanked by:  
drhma (05042012) 
#5




Quote:
great explanation good luck to u in whatever u are doing now these days
__________________
i'm so bad i make medicine sick, Imma show you how great i am 
The above post was thanked by:  
bebix (05042012) 
#6




Quote:
why not? to compare apples to apples you have to have groups matched....
__________________
Ambition is a dream with a V8 engine. EP 
#7




I believe, that when you are able to write a good question  you really aced the topic.
Tests are my weak area, but I tried to make a good one
__________________
Ambition is a dream with a V8 engine. EP 
#8




Quote:
Mc Nemar test or Logistic regression for matched p. test with robust standard errors, hahahaha... so, this is not only apple vs apple...this is apple vs apple´s sister!, hahaha 
#9




Quote:
haha ============= Multiple regression analysis will work for not matched groups, where all the comorbidites and risks, prior to surgery can be weighted individually to estimate the effect on the outcome... For matched groups: e.g. young patients with 01 comorbidites (low illness severity) of same races/ethnicity, gender and diagnosis (e.g. colon cancer will be most appropriate for right hemicolectomy, as I used in the question) Chisquare will work just fine (i used it several times), if there were less than 10pts that died in each, we could use Fisher's exact test, but thats kinda sample size that you don't wont to make a paper of haha
__________________
Ambition is a dream with a V8 engine. EP Last edited by DocSikorski; 05042012 at 11:46 AM. 
#10




Note:
If you have only nominal variable do chisquare,if you have only interval variable go for correlation,one nominal and one interval go for ttest,but if you have more than 2 variables (at least one of each) go for anova 
#11




Quote:
So...anyone of your alternatives wasnt correct...dont worry, Im a Biostatistician and X2 does not work...maybe is time to go back to the books this is the bible for categorical analysis: http://www.amazon.com/StatisticalMe...6164393&sr=81 good luck! 
#12




Quote:
chi2 works only for independent samples in case of matched data, you must use McNamer test. good luck! 
#13




Thanks, I might ask my supervisor to order it...
__________________
Ambition is a dream with a V8 engine. EP 
Tags 
BiostatisticsEpidemiology, Step1Questions 
Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Display Modes  

Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Which age groups should routinely get Influenza vaccine!  amberafzal  USMLE Step 2 CK Forum  7  10242016 09:03 PM 
Hormones Groups and Structural Similarities  rasheed  USMLE Step 1 Bits & Pieces  2  10172011 10:44 AM 
Statistical Error when CI is 2 to 12%  ricko335  USMLE Step 1 Forum  4  08302011 07:14 AM 
compare the efficacacy  ricko335  USMLE Step 1 Forum  3  08192011 06:34 AM 
confidence interval of two groups!  deji  USMLE Step 1 Forum  0  06192011 06:00 PM 
