USMLE Forums banner

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm an IMG and I just took NBME 17 yesterday.
I made 41 mistakes and I got 209, which is pretty disappointing. However, looking on the internet I found some posts (mainly from 2 years ago) from people who got around 230 making 10 mistakes less than me. These posts are mainly from 2015 and you can find it on this thread (can't post the link, look for nbme 17 discussion on studentdoctor forum)

"i got a 234 with 30 questions wrong" (apr 2015)
"I got 228 with 36 wrong" (apr 2015)
"I got 43 wrong, 450 or 217 score." (may 2015)

Any idea why they changed the curve?
Did USMLE just got harder as well or is there a bias because some questions are already being heavily tested on Uworld and so everybody started to get them right in the last 2 years?

Even though I've made some stupid mistakes on basic stuff, it's pretty depressing to know that scoring 80% will result in such a poor score
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
80 Posts
The curve has definitely changed, I myself scored 84.5% on NBME 17 and that was ONLY a 223. The new NBME 19 also has a harsh curve, however, it is better for NBMEs to be more harsh and under predict than giving us false hope that we are going to all score >240. It makes sense, just keep studying and don't be too disappointed with your practice scores.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
The curve has definitely changed, I myself scored 84.5% on NBME 17 and that was ONLY a 223. The new NBME 19 also has a harsh curve, however, it is better for NBMEs to be more harsh and under predict than giving us false hope that we are going to all score >240. It makes sense, just keep studying and don't be too disappointed with your practice scores.
yes I noticed that also for other NBMEs. for example 1 month ago I took nbme 13 and I scored 200 with 47 mistakes while a lot of people who took the simulation 2-3 years ago made around 50 mistakes and they were on the 210 range.

I wonder why they changed and I'm afraid that the predictiveness is always the same, but the USMLE level just got harder than few years ago, so scoring 80% it's not enough anymore to have a decent score in the 220 range.

Anyway have you tried the real exam yet? if yes, did NBME 17 underpredict your score
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
86 Posts
I'm an IMG and I just took NBME 17 yesterday.
I made 41 mistakes and I got 209, which is pretty disappointing. However, looking on the internet I found some posts (mainly from 2 years ago) from people who got around 230 making 10 mistakes less than me. These posts are mainly from 2015 and you can find it on this thread (can't post the link, look for nbme 17 discussion on studentdoctor forum)

"i got a 234 with 30 questions wrong" (apr 2015)
"I got 228 with 36 wrong" (apr 2015)
"I got 43 wrong, 450 or 217 score." (may 2015)

Any idea why they changed the curve?
Did USMLE just got harder as well or is there a bias because some questions are already being heavily tested on Uworld and so everybody started to get them right in the last 2 years?

Even though I've made some stupid mistakes on basic stuff, it's pretty depressing to know that scoring 80% will result in such a poor score
I gave up on predicting my score with NBME percent correct a long time ago. There is no way for us to know how the test is scored. I had the same issues as you when I was preparing. It would drive me nuts to see that I had much less incorrects and a worse score than people a few years ago. Just do your thing, compare yourself to yourself and focus on your goal. I decided to stop worrying about the mysteries of USMLE scoring.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I gave up on predicting my score with NBME percent correct a long time ago. There is no way for us to know how the test is scored. I had the same issues as you when I was preparing. It would drive me nuts to see that I had much less incorrects and a worse score than people a few years ago. Just do your thing, compare yourself to yourself and focus on your goal. I decided to stop worrying about the mysteries of USMLE scoring.
did your NBME results turn out to be predictive eventually?
My goal is 225+ and I'm a little bit more than 2 weeks out.

I took NBME 16 10 days ago and I got 211 making a lot of stupid mistakes, like getting wrong stupid stuff like calculating incidence or things ike that (I was very distracted during the simulation). Then I got 209 on NBME 17 without making any stupid mistake. I really hope that the new NBME 17 curve is not predictive of your score otherwise I'm in big trouble. I'll take nbme 18 soon and see how it will go (I've seen that the curve is much more nicer, even though it seems very challenging)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
86 Posts
did your NBME results turn out to be predictive eventually?
My goal is 225+ and I'm a little bit more than 2 weeks out.

I took NBME 16 10 days ago and I got 211 making a lot of stupid mistakes, like getting wrong stupid stuff like calculating incidence or things ike that (I was very distracted during the simulation). Then I got 209 on NBME 17 without making any stupid mistake. I really hope that the new NBME 17 curve is not predictive of your score otherwise I'm in big trouble. I'll take nbme 18 soon and see how it will go (I've seen that the curve is much more nicer, even though it seems very challenging)
I do not know yet. I am expecting my score report this Wednesday. I had 12 mistakes on NBME 18 and got 263, 9 mistakes on 17 and got a 261, 6 mistakes on 19 with a 265. I do not know how much that helps. 19 felt the most difficult to me but ended up with the least number of mistakes.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
29 Posts
I took NBME 15 a week or so back and got 213. Seems it might have changed.

According to one correlation table, Kaplan Qbank score ~ 57% = 225 and Uworld score 59% = 222. Not a a large difference, but still significant. (though I'm not sure if its because I've done <4th of the qbanks.)

Btw I just put in these numbers in that score estimator tool clinical review.com website and it was very close to my nbme score.
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top