USMLE Forums banner

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I'm a Canadian IMG, and applying for FM and Psychiatry. If the hospital won't sponsor J1 visa, should I apply for it? Someone told me that ECFMG or Canadian government would sponsor J1 for Canadian. Really getting confused about this problem, please help. Thanks a lot!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
58 Posts
do not worry

J1 Visa is supported by ECFMG. Do not worry about this.
Only thing you need to consider while applying is, whether the hospital program accepts J1 visa or not.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
I hope youre aware you need to pass the canadian boards to be eligible for a J1.
The canadian government doesnt give you the j-1, they give you the statement of need so that you can get it
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
29 Posts
BTW, I have heard that IMGs must sign a "return of service" contract with Canadian government to be eligible to obtain the statement of need ?! Is that true?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
73 Posts
I'm applying to the match year this year and I'm Canadian. I researched this topic a lot as well our school provided us a lot of information about the process.

Just to simplify to stuff:
- J1 Visa is sponsored only by the ECFMG and not by the program. Program has nothing to do with you obtaining a J1 visa, and all legal fees are paid by applicant.
- To be eligible for the J1 Visa, you must match and you must provide a statement of need from the Canadian Government (Health Canada)
- There is no pre-conditions for you to obtain a Statement of Need from Health Canada such as exams or return of service.
- Only condition of obtaining a J1 visa by the US Government is that you will need to return to your home country for 2 years prior to being able to apply for green card or any other visa.
- J1 Visa maximum length is 6 years

Big Misconception:
- You do NOT need to complete any exams such as MCCEE or MCQE1 to get Statement of Need. However, when returning to Canada to practice, you will need to complete MCCEE, MCQE1/2, and Specialty specific Boards exams.

Difference between H1b and J1:
- You will need to complete Step 3 to be eligible to obtain a H1b while it's not required for J1
- All legal fees and application fees for H1b fall on the program while J1 it does not
- Limitation in H1b visa per state while J1 there is not limitation about amount of J1 visa given out. Limitation of the J1 is obtaining a Statement of Need by Health Canada instead as there is a numbered limitation.
- H1b visa is 7 years length vs J1 is only 6 years length
- H1b visa has an option to be converted into a green card at a later time without returning home, however J1 visa must return for at least 2 years prior to applying for any status other then visitor. One exception to the limitation in J1 visa is obtaining a waiver, however that's something that is always changing in requirements and something you will need to research prior to finishing residency.

Hope this helps.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
I'm applying to the match year this year and I'm Canadian. I researched this topic a lot as well our school provided us a lot of information about the process.

Just to simplify to stuff:
- J1 Visa is sponsored only by the ECFMG and not by the program. Program has nothing to do with you obtaining a J1 visa, and all legal fees are paid by applicant.
- To be eligible for the J1 Visa, you must match and you must provide a statement of need from the Canadian Government (Health Canada)
- There is no pre-conditions for you to obtain a Statement of Need from Health Canada such as exams or return of service.
- Only condition of obtaining a J1 visa by the US Government is that you will need to return to your home country for 2 years prior to being able to apply for green card or any other visa.
- J1 Visa maximum length is 6 years

Big Misconception:
- You do NOT need to complete any exams such as MCCEE or MCQE1 to get Statement of Need. However, when returning to Canada to practice, you will need to complete MCCEE, MCQE1/2, and Specialty specific Boards exams.

Difference between H1b and J1:
- You will need to complete Step 3 to be eligible to obtain a H1b while it's not required for J1
- All legal fees and application fees for H1b fall on the program while J1 it does not
- Limitation in H1b visa per state while J1 there is not limitation about amount of J1 visa given out. Limitation of the J1 is obtaining a Statement of Need by Health Canada instead as there is a numbered limitation.
- H1b visa is 7 years length vs J1 is only 6 years length
- H1b visa has an option to be converted into a green card at a later time without returning home, however J1 visa must return for at least 2 years prior to applying for any status other then visitor. One exception to the limitation in J1 visa is obtaining a waiver, however that's something that is always changing in requirements and something you will need to research prior to finishing residency.

Hope this helps.
Thank you for your detailed reply. That means when a program says they do not "sponsor" J1 visa, they actually do not "accept" J1 visa, correct?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
73 Posts
Thank you for your detailed reply. That means when a program says they do not "sponsor" J1 visa, they actually do not "accept" J1 visa, correct?
Correct, they don't accept J1 visas. Are you applying to the match now or planning to apply next year?
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top